Miami University
  HOME SEARCH SITEMAP CONTACTS NEWS SPORTS & EVENTS
ABOUT MIAMI ACADEMICS ADMISSION LIVING AT MIAMI UNIVERSITY OFFICES
Liberal Education
Assessment
First Year Seminars
Liberal Education
Miami Plan Assessment (Program Review)
Miami Plan Courses
New Course
Proposal Forms
Petitioning
Reports
Student Success Plan
Top 25 Project
Workshops
 
Assessing Critical Thinking (ACT) Project

Rebecca Eaton, Assistant Professor, Department of Theatre, Hamilton Campus
(ACT I, Spring, 2005; ACT IV, Spring, 2008)

 

 

ACT I (Spring, 2005): THE 101: Drama and Analysis

ACT IV (Spring, 2008): THE 101: Drama and Analysis

 


ACT I (Spring, 2005): THE 101: Drama and Analysis
Ms. Eaton adapted the WSU rubric for use in her THE 101, Drama and Analysis, course.  In addition to the criteria on the WSU rubric she had categories on understanding of the play and writing mechanics.  As this is a Miami Plan Foundation course and most of the students are in their first year at Miami, she found it to be particularly important to talk to the class about what a liberal education is and what their part is in it.  She found the rubric to be useful in launching discussions about what critical thinking is and how it pertains to theatre.  In her assessment of the project, she said, “I believe they became better critical thinkers simply because they saw the logic of how a liberal arts education is supposed to work for them. They were able to conceive more readily that they were “in” on their own education. They are not receptors only, but active participants.”

Assigment

Rubric


ACT IV (Spring, 2008): THE 101: Drama and Analysis
Students in early drama analysis often have trouble discerning what might actually be in the text with what their well-trained reading minds assume. This long-term exercise was intended to refocus the students' minds to read a text in the specific fashion from the theatre practitioner's point of view. Students were introduced to the concepts of Given Circumstances, Imaginary Circumstances and Research Circumstances.

Students were given a small packet from which to work. It contained:

•  A clipping from Henrik Ibsen's A Doll House to be analyzed together in class.
•  The short play, Furniture, by Roberta Flackwood.
•  "World of the Play" two page worksheet and take-home paper instructions.
•  Furniture paper rubric.

The project was to assess their abilities after a semester of analyzing texts. Ms. Eaton also planned to use the information to find holes in her teaching. Students had helpful suggestions throughout the process and particularly at the end of it.

The beginning of the project took place over about 2.5 class periods. The class covered A Doll House. Students were given approximately three weeks to complete the assignment. Ms. Eaton learned that the project would be better if it were expanded and turned into an even longer-term assignment. She also discovered that students learned more about how the scene worked when they actually did it (stood on their feet and performed the scene.)

On the day the assignment was turned in, the class held a post-mortem discussion about it. Students' informal input centered around the fact that they wished they knew that they had more freedom than they did. When Ms. Eaton uses the assignment in the future, she has decided to not just dub them all directors, but to go over again just what a director does, is, is allowed to do, the responsibilities, etc. Also, Ms. Eaton would make a more specific rubric with the gradations marked in ways that reflect precise reasons the paper is at one end of the spectrum or the other.

"Furniture" Assignment

"Furniture" Rubric

"World of the Play" Worksheet and Instructions

 

Return to Assessing Critical Thinking (ACT) Project


 





Assessment
Welcome Page
Assessment Basics
Assessment Briefs
  Assessment Luncheons
Current Projects
Miami Plan Assessment (Program Review)
Staff